
Unconventional Ingredients
Some pagans and witches like to have certain items to incorporate into their rituals and spells. A classic example of this is rose quartz stones for healing or love workings.
There is absolutely nothing wrong with these classic correspondence ingredients. However, not everyone can afford to spend a bunch of money on fancy items. So with that in mind, this post is going to be a list of nonconventional items that can be used for magical workings and what kind of workings they are good for.

Acorn - security, abundance, longevity, good luck, youth, good health
Animal Toys/Stickers - relates to correspondences of that animal; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, etc
Birthday Candles - wishes and intentions, color correspondence magic, number correspondence magic
Black Tea Bags - (used) earth magic, grounding, strength, stability, banishing negativity, endings, death
Bottle Caps - prosperity, luck, material gain
Bubble Bath - self-love, relaxation, emotional healing, serenity, scent correspondence magic
Bubbles - wishes, joy, imagination, fantasy
Buckeye Nuts - luck, sexual energies, warding
Butter - femininity, flattery, friendship, warmth, happiness, fae work
Candy Bars - love, romance, happiness, lust, fertility, emotional healing, healing of the heart, forgiveness, friendship
Candy Foil - sweetness, secrets, protection of one's emotions, color correspondence magic; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Charcoal - (can be artist's charcoal or activated charcoal for fish tanks, for example) banishing negativity, protection, cursing, purification/cleansing
Chocolate Syrup/Milk - happiness, love, lust, romance, sweetening relationships
Clay - earth magic, grounding, balance, stability, creation, change; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Cocktail Sword - strength, assertiveness, competition, cursing, revenge, ending rumors
Cotton Balls - beauty, gentleness, warmth, sleep
Dice - chance, opportunity, luck, number correspondence magic
Dirt - grounding, earth magic, growth, prosperity, patience, home and family, cursing
Dish Soap - cleansing/purification
Duct Tape - binding, storing energy, cursing
Energy Drink - energy, motivation, creativity
Envelopes - messages, communication, protection during travel
Epsom Salts - purification, cleansing, protection, pain relief, serenity, comfort, stress relief, color correspondence magic, scent correspondence magic, bath magic
Fish Sauce - prosperity, water magic, curses
Foil - glamour, protection, storing energy, binding; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Glue - sealing, immobility, divination, curses; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Googly Eyes - vision, divination, scrying, creativity, protection, imagination, curses, paranoia, nightmares
Grass - growth, nature, learning, healing, new beginnings, recovery from loss
Hand Soap - curse removal, cleansing, purification
Hole Punch - good for cursing
Hot Sauce - motivation, lust, confidence, cursing, anger, revenge, emotional pain
Lip Balm - glamour, confidence in speaking, honesty, beauty
Lollipop - sweetness, innocence, ending rumors and lies, lust, sexual energies, love
Lotion - protection, beauty, glamour
Laundry Soap - cleansing, purification
Marshmallows - friendliness, comfort, gentleness, fidelity, sleep, dreams
Metal Crafting Wire - binding, shape correspondence magic, rune magic; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Mud - grounding, earth magic, curses
Muslin - change, creativity; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Noodles - longevity, good health
Pompoms - gentleness, comfort, love, sleep, dreams; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Paper Clips - balance, focus, organization, curses, binding
Play Money - wealth, prosperity, could be used as ancestor money
Penny - wealth, prosperity, luck
Pickle Juice - curses to sour things
Plastic Bags - protection, binding
Plastic Ribbon - happiness, glamour, delight, binding, color correspondence magic; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Plastic Wrap - binding, storing energy, cursing
Popsicle Sticks - good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Razor Blades - curses, cord-cutting, witch bottles
Recycled Bottles/Jars - good for various pagan crafting projects such as jar spells, Yule snow globes, etc
Scissors - offensive magic, curses; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, etc
Seltzer Water - purification, removing negativity, curses, flavor correspondence magic
Sewing Needles - curses, pain; also good for various pagan crafting projects such as Yule ornaments, dream catchers, wands, deity statues, poppets, witch bottles, etc
Shaving Cream - cleansing, patience, calmness, glamour, beauty
Stamps - travel, communication
Sour Cream - cursing
Soy Sauce - protection, banishment, cursing
Sticky Notes - communication, memory, color correspondence magic
Strawberry Milk - love, self-love, beauty, sweetness, friendship
Syrup - sweetening one's emotions or relationships, joy
Tissue Paper - softness, serenity, color correspondence magic
Toothpaste - cleansing, purification
Toothpick - curse
Used Tea Bags - for bath magic
Walnut Shells - protection, warding, abundance, wealth, earth magic (black walnut shells can also be used for cursing, as black walnut trees are very competitive and give out toxins to kill other plants)
Wasabi - energy, curses, anger, energy
Whipped Cream - beauty, light-heartedness
Whistles - communication, attention-grabbing, warding, raising energy